Skip to main content
Breast Pumps

Breast Pump vs. Manual Pump: Which One is Right for You?

Breast Pump vs. Manual Pump: Which One is Right for You?

Having a baby is an exciting and challenging journey. One of the most important things to consider as a new mom is how you will feed your baby. Breastfeeding is a popular choice, but it might not always be possible or convenient. That’s why breast pumps were invented: to allow moms to express milk so that their babies can be fed with breast milk even when the mom is not around. But with so many options out there, it can be hard to know which type of breast pump is right for you. In this article, we’ll dive deeper into the differences between breast pumps and manual pumps so that you can make an informed decision.

What is a Breast Pump?

A breast pump is a device that’s designed to help moms extract breast milk from their breasts. The pump mimics the natural sucking of a baby, stimulating the breast to release milk. Breast pumps can come in different types, including electric, battery-powered, and manual.

What is a Manual Pump?

A manual pump is a simpler version of the breast pump. It requires no electricity or batteries and is operated by hand. The user needs to create suction by squeezing a handle on the pump, which then stimulates the breast to release milk. Manual pumps are usually more affordable than electric pumps and are much easier to travel with.

Advantages of a Breast Pump

Electric breast pumps are much more efficient than manual pumps. They can extract milk faster, which means you’ll need less time to pump. They’re also ideal if you plan on returning to work and you don’t have a lot of time for pumping. Electric pumps are usually more comfortable than manual pumps, and they allow you to adjust the suction strength and speed, which can increase milk production and prevent nipple soreness.

Advantages of a Manual Pump

Manual pumps are much less expensive than electric pumps, so they’re a great option for moms on a budget. They also require no electricity, making them ideal if you’re traveling or don’t have access to an electrical outlet. Manual pumps are also very quiet, making them a great choice if you need to pump discreetly. They’re also lightweight and portable, which makes them easy to use and store.

Disadvantages of a Breast Pump

Electric pumps can be expensive, especially if you purchase a high-end model. They also require access to electricity, which can be a problem if you’re traveling or live in an area with frequent power outages. Some electric pumps can be noisy, which can make it hard to use them discreetly. They’re also bulkier than manual pumps, which makes them less portable.

Disadvantages of a Manual Pump

Manual pumps are slower than electric pumps, which means you’ll need to spend more time pumping. They also require more effort to use, which can cause hand and wrist fatigue. Manual pumps are not ideal if you need to express a lot of milk, as the suction is not as strong as an electric pump. If you plan on pumping often, a manual pump might not be the best option for you.


In summary, the type of breast pump you choose depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you plan on pumping often, an electric pump might be the better choice, as it’s more efficient and comfortable. However, if you’re on a budget, travel frequently, or don’t need to pump often, a manual pump might be the better option for you. Whether you choose a breast pump or manual pump, the most important thing is that you’re able to provide your baby with the nutrition they need to grow and thrive.

Breast Pump vs. Manual Pump: Which One is Right for You? – FAQ

1. What is the difference between a breast pump and a manual pump?

A breast pump uses an electric or battery-powered motor to remove milk from the breasts, while a manual pump requires the mother to manually use her own hand to create suction to express milk.

2. What are the benefits of using a breast pump?

Using a breast pump can help mothers who have trouble breastfeeding or need to increase milk supply. It can also help working mothers feed their babies breast milk when they are away. Breast pumps also allow for easier feedings for mothers of multiples or premature babies.

3. What are the benefits of using a manual pump?

A manual pump is quieter and more portable than an electric pump. It is also less expensive and easier to clean. Some mothers find that the ability to control the suction manually makes it more comfortable to use than an electric pump.

4. Which is better for building milk supply: a breast pump or a manual pump?

A breast pump is generally more effective at building milk supply than a manual pump. It is more efficient at emptying the breasts, which signals the body to make more milk.

5. Which type of pump is better for travelling?

A manual pump is generally better for travelling because it is smaller and quieter. It can be easily packed in a suitcase or diaper bag and used discreetly in public places.

6. Is a breast pump or a manual pump more comfortable to use?

This is a personal preference and may vary from mother to mother. Some may find a manual pump more comfortable because they can control the suction, while others may prefer the ease of use and efficiency of an electric pump.

7. Can a manual pump be used to exclusively pump?

While it is possible to exclusively pump with a manual pump, it may be more difficult and time-consuming than using an electric pump. It may be beneficial to use a manual pump as a backup or for occasional use.

8. How often should I pump?

This will depend on your individual needs and circumstances. Generally, it is recommended to pump every 2-3 hours during the day and once during the night to maintain milk supply and avoid engorgement.

9. How do I clean my breast pump and manual pump?

Both breast pumps and manual pumps should be cleaned after each use with soap and water and sterilized once a day. Check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific cleaning recommendations.

10. Should I buy a breast pump or rent one?

This will depend on how frequently the pump will be used. If the pump will be used long-term or for multiple children, it may be more cost-effective to purchase a pump. If it will only be used for a short period of time, renting may be a more practical option.

Related Products: Breast Pump Comparison Tips

When it comes to selecting a breast pump, there are a ton of options on the market. It can be overwhelming to know where to start! We’ve compiled a list of recommended products to help in your search for the perfect breast pump.

  • Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump
  • The Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump is a hospital-grade, yet portable option that provides a comfortable pumping experience. With a rechargeable battery and customizable settings, this pump is perfect for moms on-the-go or those who need to pump frequently. The adjustable suction and letdown modes mimic a baby’s natural feeding patterns.

  • Medela Pump In Style Advanced Breast Pump
  • The Medela Pump In Style Advanced Breast Pump is a trusted and established option that has been on the market for years. This pump features a two-phase expression technology that mimics a baby’s natural nursing patterns, as well as adjustable suction settings. The pump comes in an easy-to-carry tote bag that fits your pump, bottles, and all your necessary pumping accessories.

  • Lansinoh Smartpump Double Electric Breast Pump
  • The Lansinoh Smartpump Double Electric Breast Pump is a hospital-strength pump that offers Bluetooth connectivity to track your pumping patterns and history through the Lansinoh Baby App. This pump features three customizable pumping styles, adjustable suction levels, and a closed system to prevent milk backflow. The compact size and quiet operation make it ideal for on-the-go pumping.

  • Momcozy Automatic Double Electric Breast Pump
  • The Momcozy Automatic Double Electric Breast Pump provides a hands-free pumping experience while allowing you to adjust the suction level and pumping mode. It’s lightweight and portable, making it easy to pump wherever you need to be. The four modes mimic a baby’s natural feeding patterns, and the LCD display screen allows you to see your pumping status at a glance.

  • Elvie Double Electric Wearable Smart Breast Pump
  • The Elvie Double Electric Wearable Smart Breast Pump is a hands-free, wireless option that fits discreetly in your nursing bra, allowing you to pump while doing other activities. The pump comes with a free app that tracks your milk volume, tracks your pumping history, and provides you with personalized pumping tips. The seven intensity levels are customizable to mimic your baby’s natural feeding patterns.

  • Haakaa Silicone Manual Breast Pump
  • The Haakaa Silicone Manual Breast Pump is a great option for moms looking for an inexpensive, yet effective breast pump. This pump is made from 100% food-grade silicone, is easy to clean, and is perfect for catching letdown while nursing on the opposite breast. Simply squeeze the pump and attach to your breast for an easy and comfortable pumping experience.

Whether you’re a first-time mom or a seasoned pro, finding the right breast pump can make all the difference in your breastfeeding journey. Take into consideration the frequency of use, customization options, and portability when selecting the right pump for you. We hope this list helps make your decision a little bit easier!

Pros & Cons: Breast Pump vs. Manual Pump

When it comes to choosing a breast pump, there are several factors to consider. Depending on your lifestyle and individual needs, a breast pump can either be a necessity or an optional tool. Below is a list of pros and cons to help you decide which pump is right for you.

Pros of Breast Pump

  • Efficient: A breast pump is an efficient way to express milk quickly while freeing up your hands to multitask or perform other tasks.
  • Adjustable: Most breast pumps come with adjustable suction levels and speed, which can mimic your baby’s sucking pattern. This feature increases comfort and helps to stimulate milk production.
  • Increased Milk Supply: Breast pumps are known to increase milk supply by efficiently removing milk from the breast, leading to an increased production of milk in the long run.
  • Convenience: With a breast pump, you can store breast milk for later use, allowing you to maintain a consistent feeding routine for your baby without the need for formula.
  • More Efficient Than Manual Pumps: Breast pumps are generally faster and more efficient at expressing milk than manual pumps. They can extract milk equally from both breasts and save you time in the long run.

Cons of Breast Pump

  • Expensive: Breast pumps can be quite costly, especially the electric varieties. Some insurers cover pump costs, which could reduce the expenses.
  • Noisy: Breast pumps can be loud and distracting, especially with the electric variety. The noise can be a nuisance and make it difficult to express milk in public or around other people.
  • Inconvenient: Breast pumps can be heavy and bulky, making them inconvenient for travel or transportation. They can take up a lot of space, and may require a power source or batteries if it’s electric.
  • Requires Cleaning: Breast pumps must be cleaned carefully after every use to avoid contamination and infection. The parts can be time-consuming to clean, especially during busy periods.
  • Not As Stimulating: Although breast pumps can mimic the sucking pattern of a baby, they don’t provide the same bonding experience as feeding your baby directly from the breast.

Pros of Manual Pump

  • Cost: A manual breast pump is considerably less expensive compared to an electric one. It is affordable for individuals who want a pump but are on a tight budget.
  • Quiet: Manual pumps are much quieter than electric pumps. They can be used almost anywhere without drawing attention or disturbing other people.
  • No Power Source: Manual pumps do not require power or batteries, making them ideal for travel or use in remote areas where there is a limited supply of electricity.
  • Ease of Use: Manual pumps are simple, easy-to-use, and require fewer parts; hence they’re less complicated than electric ones.
  • Mimics Natural Suction: The suction level can be easily adjusted to mimic your baby’s natural sucking pattern, leading to maximum comfort and milk expression.

Cons of Manual Pump

  • Requires Manual effort: Manual pumps require you to use your hands to create suction, which can be strenuous and tiring for your hands if you have to pump frequently.
  • Less Efficient: Manual pumps are generally less efficient in expressing milk, which can take more time compared to electric pumps, especially if you need to pump a large amount of milk.
  • Less Milk Production: Manual pumps can be less effective than electric pumps in milk production, leading to a decrease in milk supply over time if you rely on it too often.
  • Satisfaction: Manual pumps cannot replicate the bond that occurs during a breastfeeding session, hence it lacks that satisfaction that comes with breastfeeding.
  • Noisy: Manual pumps can make noise, although less loud than electric pumps; however, they can be disruptive or distracting.

In conclusion, choosing a breast pump comes down to individual needs and preference. Consider factors such as convenience, cost, efficiency, and lifestyle when choosing between a breast pump and manual pump.

Leave a Reply

Close Menu